It's Halloween Night, 2008 and the Valley Village apartment complex in sleepy Redwood, outside of Seattle, is having a party. By morning, one of the party's hosts is murdered. All partygoers are the main suspects - was it the guy in the devil mask, the guy dressed like Jesus, the bank robber, the construction worker? True-crime podcast veterans Mathew Shaer and Eric Benson return to the scene of the crime to uncover what happened a decade ago. Multiple suspects with botched police work, the glaring question is "did they get it right or wrong?" True crime podcasts can be hard to stomach, but what we like about listening to this genre is the look into the justice system. This case is heavily weighted on DNA evidence. Doesn't DNA always mean guilty? Listen to find out.